Excellence in Computer Simulation

Organized and sponsored by

The Network for Computational Nanotechnology (NCN)
The Center of Integrated Nanomechanical Systems (COINS)
The Molecular Foundry at Lawrence Berkeley National Lab

When and Where

November 6, 2007
University of California at Berkeley
The Bancroft Hotel
2680 Bancroft WayM
Berkeley, CA 94704

Overview

Computational science is frequently labeled as a third branch of science - equal in standing with theory and experiment. Computational engineering is now an essential component of technology development and manufacturing. The successes of computational science and engineering (CSE) over the past two-three decades have been substantial, but at the beginning of a new century, it is useful to reflect on what has been accomplished, on how computational science and engineering are evolving, and on how we can be even more successful in the future. A conversation along these lines has already begun. For example, Leo Kadanoff has encouraged computational experts to move beyond simply verifying experiments and play a more assertive role in leading science [1]. Greg Wilson argues that computational scientists don’t follow practices of documentation and preservation of data that experimentalists expect of themselves [2]. Douglass Post and Lawrence Votta assert that computational science needs a new paradigm [4]. The objective of this forum is not to develop a consensus or a strategic plan for computational science and engineering. It is simply to begin a discussion within the Network for Computational Nanotechnology (NCN), as we begin to chart our long-term future. It’s also an opportunity for NCN students, who are preparing themselves for careers in computational science and engineering, to think about how they prepare themselves for careers in CSE. And this might spark a discussion within the broader community of computational experts and others.

The plan is to bring together 1-2 dozen experts who have made strong contributions to CSE and who have also thought deeply about the field. The one-day event will include individual talks and discussion. The event will be recorded in video and voiced PowerPoint formats and disseminated through the nanoHUB (www.nanoHUB.org). We hope to see a written summary of the forum and the main ideas and issues discussed published in an academic journal / magazine. By widely disseminating the forum, we hope to provide a resource for students preparing for careers in science and engineering and to simulate a broader discussion within the NCN and across the national and international research community.

Background Informtation

Leo P. Kadanoff, “Excellence in Computer Simulation,” Computing in Science and Engineering, pp. 57-67, March/April 2004.

Greg Wilson, “Where’s the Real Bottleneck in Scientific Computing?” American Scientist, pp. 5-6, Vol. 94, Jan../Feb. 2006.

Douglass E. Post and Lawrence G. Votta, “Computational Science Demands a New Paradigm,” Physics Today, pp. 35-41, Jan. 2005.

Bradley A. Shadwick, “On the Role and Place of Computation in Science and Engineering – The Role of Computation in Physics,” Computing in Science and Engineering, pp. 101-103, Jan./Feb. 2007.

Leo P. Kadanoff, “Computational Scenarios,” Physics Today, pp. 10-11, Nov.2004.

Greg Wilson, “Software Carpentry: Getting Scientists to Write Better Code by Making Them More Productive,” Computing in Science and Engineering, pp. 66-69, Nov./Dec 2006.

Computation as a Tool for Discovery in Physics, A report to the National Science Foundation by the Steering Committee on Computational Physics, Bill McCurdy, Chair, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Simulation-Based Engineering Science: Revolutionizing Engineering Science Through Simulation, Report of the National Science Foundation Blue Ribbon Panel on Simulation-Based Engineering Science, J. Tinsley Oden, chair, May 2006.

Cyberinfrastructure Vision for 21st Century Discovery, National Science Foundation Cyberinfrastructure Council, March 2007

Ian Foster, “A two way street to science/s future,” Nature, Vol. 440, p. 419, March 2006.